Out of Tune with Domesticity
Ineffective Parents Send their Children to Preschool.
The past few weeks there’s been an internal battle going on in my head over whether or not to place Adrien in a preschool program or not. Apparently, as I did some research, parents are warring over this too. There seem to be two camps on this issue — as divided are breastfeeding moms and formula moms. I dare say that this may even go as deep as stay at home moms vs. working moms…whatever either of those battles are actually about.
I’d always just assumed that preschool was the way to go. It seems like just about everyone I know is going to put their kid in one at some point. Stay at home moms everywhere rely on “Mother’s Day Out” programs. I’d never considered that some parents actually feel that putting your child into one of these, or any other preschool before the “Pre-K” age is sort of cheating. I was chatting with a friend the other day, when I mentioned finding Adrien a preschool. We all know I’d batted the option of returning to work around, but she was even a little surprised I think to find out that I was still looking for schooling options for him after I didn’t get the position. She said her husband would never go for it. That there was absolutely no reason for her children to go a preschool if she was at home and could teach them. She spoke of putting her child in a pre-k before kindergarten…but mainly as a way to transition to being at home all day every day, to being in school every day all day; since here in Texas, most schools have done away with half-day kindergarten.
And thus the internal dialogue began.
I started to doubt my decision; my eagerness to start Adrien into preschool.
I read up on it. I read up on whether or not preschool was needed; what people were saying. There’s no evidence to suggest that preschool does much more for a child cognitively than a child who stays at home with their parent. While children may be a little more socially ready after attending a preschool, there are just as many studies that say they aren’t any more scholastically ready than studies that say they are. Parents on message boards all over the web are simply stating that sending your child to preschool is a waste of time…that as parents, we can teach them all they need to know.
But what if that isn’t the case?
I don’t know if it’s just a huge case of self doubt here, but I really don’t feel capable of teaching him all he needs to know before he enters kindergarten in two years. I honestly don’t. He doesn’t seem to want to learn from me. He’s just not interested. I feel like I’ve hit a scholastic road block with him. It’s apparent, however, that he flourishes in social environments with other adults as his instructor. At church, for instance, he learns so much — just from the few hours a week he’s in Sunday School. I just feel that as a parent, I am not cut out to teach him all he needs to know before school. But does that make me inadequate? Does that make me less qualified as a parent? Does it somehow effect my parental integrity?
I have a friend who taught her three year old to read. Her daughter is astoundingly smart, yes, but you can’t deny that there must be something to the mother’s ability to teach, right? I have other friends who are blown away by how this woman teaches things — whether it’s to children or adults. She just has that gift. To teach. I? However, do not. I was the one in high school and college that simply found it easier to do others’ work rather than show them how. I just get too frustrated in the how. I am not a good teacher.
So is there anything wrong with the decision I’ve made to send Adrien to preschool? I think it’s responsible parenting to do so if you don’t feel qualified to prepare your child for school…and I don’t think there’s anything wrong or fallible in admitting that. Teachers teach because they’re good at it. I parent because I’m a mother. In doing so, I’ve decided that academia is best presented to my children from those in a school setting. So why do I feel like lesser of a mom? Am I lesser of a mom?
Are preschools glorified day-cares? And am I being lazy? I don’t know. What I do know is this is a war that’s been playing out in my head for a while now…and preschool won.
He starts on Tuesday.
| Print article | This entry was posted by b on August 20, 2009 at 8:30 pm, and is filed under Uncategorized. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
about 1 year ago
Remember that back when there was no preschool — and mom’s didn’t work — there were usually several generations living in the same house. Kinda like the Waltons, the kids learned as much, perhaps more from grandma, grandpa, aunts, uncles as they do mom and dad. Homes are not like that anymore and something has to replace that. So, it’s a preschool for Adrien. I think it takes more to be ready for kindergarden and first grade than it used to. Nothing against you, you are a great mom! If your weren’t this wouldn’t bother you like it does. I’ll take a mom like you anyday over one who doesn’t try and do what might be better for her children just because her husband wouldn’t stand for it.
about 1 year ago
Like everything else in parenting, you have to do what works for your family. Don’t fret about what everyone else is saying. You know your families abilities and readiness better than anyone else.
about 1 year ago
I agree with Katheryn….You need to do what works for your family.
And for preschool….it doesn’t matter, by 3rd grade most children are on a level playing field. (That’s why they start testing in 3rd grade).
Adrien going to have a blast and have so many new friends. It will be a great experience for you both:)
We miss you!
about 1 year ago
I believe I would even go so far as to say that it depends on the child. Our son, the oldest, had no preschool instruction other than what I gave it him at home. He learned his letters, shapes and colors, but did not read until after he started kindergarten. Once there, he began to excel on his own and had no trouble adjusting.
I returned to work when our daughter, the youngest was just 2 1/2. She was home with her father during the day (he worked nights), but he did not give her any kind of instruction. She had a very hard time adjusting to school and almost seemed a little behind. They had no free pre-k programs back then or I would’ve put her in one – even if I had been home with her, she needed more than what I felt I could do for her.
So, it not only depends on what works for your family, but what each individual child needs. If you feel that Adrien will benefit from preschool, then by all means, he should go. You are not being lazy – and yes, for some family’s, preschool is like a glorified daycare, but that is not why you are sending him. Pay no attention to the nay-sayers, and go with your gut instinct.
about 1 year ago
I bet your “friend” that was surprised to still put him in preschool after you decided not to go to work meant nothing more by her surprise than she assumed you were only putting him in preschool because it was better than a daycare, but you still needed someone to watch him while you were at work…so when you said you weren’t going to work she just assumed he wasn’t go into a preschool then. I also bet she thinks that you are NOT a bad parent for doing what you feel is right for your own son! And that maybe she’d be doing the same thing in a year or two if her husband wasn’t against it!
So stop second guessing yourself! You are his mother and you need to do what’s right for you both…and if you don’t do what you think is right and only listen to others…then and only then are you a bad parent!!
I’m excited to hear how Adrien likes his new school! I bet he’ll just love it!
)
about 1 year ago
Can’t even believe you’re even feeling the slightest amount of guilt by sending your kid to preschool. My oldest has been going since he’s 2 and I’m a SAHM. His first experience was a co-op, so I worked in the classroom. It was a really great experience for both of us. So fun to watch him experience new things and interact with other kids. I made good friends there, too. The next year, I sent him to a drop-off program, mainly because I had another child and couldn’t do the co-op commitment. He’s now in pre-k and is a smart kid, but I don’t necessarily attribute that to preschool. We spend a lot of time reading to him and exposing him to different things. Here’s what I think preschool is the best for: social skills, keeping kids engaged–without TV, and just as important, a break for mom. I’m such a better mom when I get a break from my kids.
about 10 months ago
I am facing the same problem as you do. My husband just asked me tonight is that the right decision to send our 2 year old daughter to preschool. I wanted to send her to preschool because several reasons. I want my daughter to be more social with other children. She is very shy girl. I am worried about I am not able to teach her all the academic stuff before she enter the Kindergarten since English is my second language. I tried hard not to let my daughter expose to too much TV but it is very hard to do it. That required to offer a lot of activities to do with her. The last reason I wanted to send her to preschool is I need a break. I am 24/7 for my girl. I am often feeling really tired without family supports. My husband works really hard and comes homes late. I don’t have any family members live close by. My husband is going for a business trip soon. It is about 3 weeks. What should I do? I believe most of the mom would like to do the best for their child and for themselves. I totally agree Kim said, “I’m such a better mom when I get a break from my kids.” I feel the same way.